Comparison

Guard-Tex vs Coban: Which Self-Adhering Tape is Better?

Both are self-adhering tapes, but they're designed for different purposes. Here's how they compare — and which one is right for your needs.

Feature Guard-Tex 3M Coban
Stretch Non-stretch (holds position) Elastic (stretches 50%+)
Primary Use Finger/hand protection Compression wrapping
Residue Zero residue Zero residue
Durability Lasts full shifts/sessions May loosen over time
Grip Support Maintains tension under load Stretches under load
Compression Not designed for compression Excellent for compression
Made in USA Since 1935 Varies by product
Price Premium Moderate

The Key Difference: Stretch

Coban is designed to stretch — it's a compression bandage. That's exactly what you want for holding a dressing in place or providing light compression to a sprain. But stretch is the enemy of grip support and finger protection.

When you crimp on a climbing hold or grip a wire during a pull, you need tape that stays where you put it. Coban stretches under load, loosening exactly when you need support most. Guard-Tex doesn't stretch — it maintains tension throughout the task.

When to Use Coban

Coban excels at compression wrapping: holding gauze in place, wrapping sprains, securing IV lines. If you need tape that conforms to body contours and provides gentle compression, Coban is the right choice.

When to Use Guard-Tex

Guard-Tex is purpose-built for hand and finger protection during work and sport. Electricians pulling wire, climbers protecting pulleys, healthcare workers avoiding adhesive on fragile skin — these are Guard-Tex applications where non-stretch performance matters.

The Verdict

They're not competitors — they're different tools. Coban for compression, Guard-Tex for protection. If you need grip support, finger protection, or tape that won't loosen under load, Guard-Tex is the clear choice.

Try Guard-Tex